Searchlight Logo
special_image

    • News
      • Front Page
      • News
      • Breaking News
      • Press Release
      • Features
      • Special Features
      • From the Courts
      • Sports
      • Regional / World
    • Opinions
      • Editorial
      • Our Readers’ Opinions
      • Bassy – Love Vine
      • Dr. Fraser- Point of View
      • R. Rose – Eye of the Needle
      • On Target
      • Dr Jozelle Miller
      • The World Around Us
      • Random Thoughts
    • Advice
      • Kitchen Corner
      • What’s on Fleek this week
      • Health Wise
      • Physician’s Weekly
      • Business Buzz
      • Hey Rosie!
      • Prime the pump
    • ePaper
    • Obituaries
      • In Memoriam / Acknowledgement
      • Tribute
    • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Letters To The Editor
      • General Contact Information
      • Contact our Webmaster
    • About Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Interactive Media Ltd
      • St. Vincent & the Grenadines
    • Subscribe
    • News
      • Front Page
      • News
      • Breaking News
      • Press Release
      • Features
      • Special Features
      • From the Courts
      • Sports
      • Regional / World
    • Opinions
      • Editorial
      • Our Readers’ Opinions
      • Bassy – Love Vine
      • Dr. Fraser- Point of View
      • R. Rose – Eye of the Needle
      • On Target
      • Dr Jozelle Miller
      • The World Around Us
      • Random Thoughts
    • Advice
      • Kitchen Corner
      • What’s on Fleek this week
      • Health Wise
      • Physician’s Weekly
      • Business Buzz
      • Hey Rosie!
      • Prime the pump
    • ePaper
    • Obituaries
      • In Memoriam / Acknowledgement
      • Tribute
    • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Letters To The Editor
      • General Contact Information
      • Contact our Webmaster
    • About Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Interactive Media Ltd
      • St. Vincent & the Grenadines
    • Subscribe
Understanding the Law
July 27, 2012

A dissenting judgment

Last week we looked at the judgment of Chief Justice Sir Dennis Byron given in two matters, Newton Spence v the Queen, No 20 of 1998 and Peter Hughes v the Queen, which, because of certain similarities, were consolidated. Justice Adrian Saunders concurred with this judgment. This week we will take a look at the judgment of Justice Albert Redhead, the lone dissenting voice in the matter.{{more}}

Before we actually get into the reasoning of the honourable judge, we must be reminded that the Privy Council remitted the two cases to the Court of Appeal for its consideration, because both appeals had raised a similar constitutional issue with regard to sentencing. The justices of appeal were required to consider whether “(a) the mandatory sentence of death imposed on the offenders should be quashed (and if so what sentence including the sentence of death should be imposed or (b) the mandatory sentence of death imposed on the appellant ought to be affirmed.”

Like the Chief Justice, Justice Redhead looked at the issue of construction, since it relates to matters contained in the constitution, namely the fundamental rights and freedom of the individual. In the above named cases, the issue of construction is particularly important to determine whether the mandatory death sentence was contrary to the section that opposes cruel and degrading punishment, or that which speaks of the arbitrary deprivation of a person’s life.

Justice Redhead, like the Chief Justice, looked at the constitution of St Lucia and opined that the fundamental rights and freedom were similar to those in St Vincent and the Grenadines. He felt that they were not substantive rights, but declaratory of rights that the populace should enjoy. He took issue with the submission by learned Queen Counsel Mr Fitzgerald, who opined that section 2(1) of the constitution was essentially a guarantee that a person would not be “arbitrarily deprived of one’s life”.

Justice Redhead insists that there was no guarantee in section 2(1). This section states that a person shall not be deprived of his life intentionally, save in the execution of a sentence of a court, in respect of a criminal offence of which he has been convicted. According to Justice Redhead, a person who commits murder and was found guilty by a jury could not be said to be “arbitrarily deprived of his life”, since there was due process.

Justice Redhead also looked at the savings clause and came to the conclusion that “before any remedial act of construction could be employed by way of modification etc. the law must offend the constitution.”

He felt that the punishment authorized by law would not become illegal, because there was no mitigation. In the case of the individuals in the above named case, he did not think that the lack of mitigation caused the decision to hang convicted offenders to be arbitrary. He pointed to the question of the “variation of moral blameworthiness of persons convicted of murder,” raised by Lord Diplock in Ong Ah Chaun v. Public Prosecutor. (1981) AC 648. Moral blameworthiness did not make the mandatory sentence that is lawful become unlawful.

The essence of Justice Redhead’s judgment is brought out in the following comment: “We must heed Lord Wilberforce’s reminder that a constitution is a legal instrument, the language of which must be respected. If the language given by lawgivers is ignored in favour of general resort to “values”, the result is not interpretation but divination.”

Ada Johnson is a solicitor and barrister-at-law.
E-mail address is: exploringthelaw@yahoo.com

  • FacebookComments
  • ALSO IN THE NEWS
    Villa woman in  hospital after being stabbed over 20 times
    Front Page
    Villa woman in hospital after being stabbed over 20 times
    Webmaster 
    September 9, 2025
    Police are said to be carrying out investigations into the stabbing of Rafia Sardine, a 20-year-old female of Villa. Reports are that Sardine, a FLOW ...
    RSVGPF most hacked of gov’t agencies
    Front Page
    RSVGPF most hacked of gov’t agencies
    Webmaster 
    September 9, 2025
    In St Vincent and the Grenadines (SVG), an analysis has found that the most hacked government entity was the Royal St Vincent and the Grenadines Polic...
    Event staged locally to mark Africa/ Caricom Day
    Front Page
    Event staged locally to mark Africa/ Caricom Day
    Webmaster 
    September 9, 2025
    Leaders of Governments and institutions from countries of the Caribbean Community (CARICOM), and the continent of Africa, gathered at the weekend for ...
    PM, proud of his constituents
    Front Page
    PM, proud of his constituents
    Webmaster 
    September 9, 2025
    Prime Minister, Dr Ralph Gonsalves, is proud of the persons in his constituency who continue to aim for higher education. Dr Gonsalves is the parliame...
    Van conductor to be sentenced for beating pregnant ex-girlfriend
    Front Page
    Van conductor to be sentenced for beating pregnant ex-girlfriend
    Webmaster 
    September 9, 2025
    A van conductor, who beat his five- months pregnant ex-girlfriend after she refused to get back with him, has been remanded pending sentencing. Onez J...
    King selected again for the ULP in West St George
    News
    King selected again for the ULP in West St George
    Webmaster 
    September 9, 2025
    To the haunting timeless reggae melody of Jimmy Cliff’s classic ‘Journey’, Curtis King, who was selected as the candidate for the Unity Labour Party (...
    News
    King selected again for the ULP in West St George
    News
    King selected again for the ULP in West St George
    Webmaster 
    September 9, 2025
    To the haunting timeless reggae melody of Jimmy Cliff’s classic ‘Journey’, Curtis King, who was selected as the candidate for the Unity Labour Party (...
    Steel wielding Lowman’s Hill man to be sentenced tomorrow
    From the Courts, News
    Steel wielding Lowman’s Hill man to be sentenced tomorrow
    Webmaster 
    September 9, 2025
    A Lowman’s Hill man who struck another villager in his head with a piece of steel will know his fate tomorrow, September 10, 2025. Kevin Roberts, 25, ...
    Minister of Information Technology  emphasises the importance of Cybersecurity
    News
    Minister of Information Technology emphasises the importance of Cybersecurity
    Webmaster 
    September 5, 2025
    Robust cybersecurity must be at the heart of the digital transformation that is currently taking place in St Vincent and the Grenadines (SVG) says Min...
    Entities team up to boost disaster communication capacity
    News
    Entities team up to boost disaster communication capacity
    Webmaster 
    September 5, 2025
    The Climate Change Resilience Network (CCRN) in collaboration with the Youlou Radio Movement (YRM) recently embarked on a disaster preparedness initia...
    Ministry of Health to get more dialysis machines
    News
    Ministry of Health to get more dialysis machines
    Webmaster 
    September 5, 2025
    The Ministry of Health, Wellness and the Environment, is to obtain three more Heamodialysis machines as part of the revolution in the healthcare secto...

    E-EDITION
    ePaper
    google_play
    app_store
    Subscribe Now
    • Interactive Media Ltd. • P.O. Box 152 • Kingstown • St. Vincent and the Grenadines • Phone: 784-456-1558 © Copyright Interactive Media Ltd.. All rights reserved.
    We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok