Searchlight Logo
special_image

    • News
      • Front Page
      • News
      • Breaking News
      • Press Release
      • Features
      • Special Features
      • From the Courts
      • Sports
      • Regional / World
    • Opinions
      • Editorial
      • Our Readers’ Opinions
      • Bassy – Love Vine
      • Dr. Fraser- Point of View
      • R. Rose – Eye of the Needle
      • On Target
      • Dr Jozelle Miller
      • The World Around Us
      • Random Thoughts
    • Advice
      • Kitchen Corner
      • What’s on Fleek this week
      • Health Wise
      • Physician’s Weekly
      • Business Buzz
      • Hey Rosie!
      • Prime the pump
    • ePaper
    • Obituaries
      • In Memoriam / Acknowledgement
      • Tribute
    • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Letters To The Editor
      • General Contact Information
      • Contact our Webmaster
    • About Us
      • Interactive Media Ltd
      • St. Vincent & the Grenadines
    • Subscribe
    • News
      • Front Page
      • News
      • Breaking News
      • Press Release
      • Features
      • Special Features
      • From the Courts
      • Sports
      • Regional / World
    • Opinions
      • Editorial
      • Our Readers’ Opinions
      • Bassy – Love Vine
      • Dr. Fraser- Point of View
      • R. Rose – Eye of the Needle
      • On Target
      • Dr Jozelle Miller
      • The World Around Us
      • Random Thoughts
    • Advice
      • Kitchen Corner
      • What’s on Fleek this week
      • Health Wise
      • Physician’s Weekly
      • Business Buzz
      • Hey Rosie!
      • Prime the pump
    • ePaper
    • Obituaries
      • In Memoriam / Acknowledgement
      • Tribute
    • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Letters To The Editor
      • General Contact Information
      • Contact our Webmaster
    • About Us
      • Interactive Media Ltd
      • St. Vincent & the Grenadines
    • Subscribe
Understanding the Law
June 15, 2007

Privy Council Decision 3

Last week we discussed the grounds raised in Court of Appeal No 10 of 2006 between Bernard Coard and others and the Attorney General of Grenada and the reasoning of their Lordships of the Privy Council. This week we will commence where we left off.

Constitutional right to appeal

Counsel for the appellant pointed out that the appellants had been denied their constitutional right to appeal and to this their Lordship pointed to the case of Mitchell v Director of Public Prosecutions which had dealt with the issue.{{more}} In that case it was noted that the right was abolished by People’s Law No 84 of 1979, instituted under the revolutionary government and was confirmed by Act No 1 of 1985 by the constitutional government. Restoration of appeal to the Privy Council came in 1991 but could not operate to afford the appellant the right to appeal.

Counsel went on to ask for leave to challenge the constitutionality of the appellants convictions in 1986, but their Lordships noted that this point was already resolved in the case of Chokolingo v the Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago where it was argued against the use of a constitutional motion “to avoid the finality of a decision dismissing a criminal appeal”. They argued that in a similar case in Canada the same issue was raised and the Supreme Court held that the appellant could not use a collateral procedure to reopen the question of whether his conviction had been lawful. If an appeal is still open then the issue could be revisited.

After dealing with the minor issues their Lordships turned to the central submission in the appeal, that is, that the mandatory sentence of the death penalty was unconstitutional. As said before, the Caribbean Court of Appeal led by Byron CJ had in the Case of Regina v Hughes [2002] 2 AC 259 held that the mandatory death penalty was an “inhuman or degrading punishment and unconstitutional”. Their Lordships noted that this point was also made in relation to other constitutions in several cases in the Caribbean and based on section 230 of the Grenada constitution which came into being in 1974 the death penalty for murder was discretionary. With this interpretation it means that a person convicted of murder is not automatically given the death sentence but may be given a lesser sentence. In the case before them, their Lordships therefore concluded that the death sentence was unlawful.

Their Lordships also noted that Byron J, the judge who conducted the trial had applied the correct law that was in existence at the time but “there was no judicial contribution to determining the sentence which they should have served”, in fact no discretion was exercised.

They looked at the existing mechanism in Grenada for sentencing and pointed to the prerogative of mercy but thought it was inadequate and was dependent on executive discretion. They also noted that there was a provision in the Prison Rules to review sentences for life prisoners by a Board and they relied on Benjamin J, who said that the Board had either never been appointed or had not functioned “.

Their Lordships felt that there was “the highly unusual circumstance in that the question of the fate of the appellants was “politically charged that it is hardly reasonable to expect any Government of Grenada even 23 years after the tragic events of October1983 to take an objective view of the matter”, They therefore recommended a judicial determination so that appropriate sentences could be arrived at, taking into consideration “such progress” as the appellants have made in prison”

Ada Johnson is a solicitor and barrister-at-law.
E-mail address is: exploringthelaw@yahoo.com

  • FacebookComments
  • ALSO IN THE NEWS
    Pharmacist in Calder shooting granted $30,000 bail
    Front Page
    Pharmacist in Calder shooting granted $30,000 bail
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    A Pharmacist, charged with attempted murder, has been granted bail in the sum of $30,000. Esworth Lewis, who is alleged to have shot a man about his b...
    Bigger things in store  for former SVG Consul General to Toronto – PM
    Front Page
    Bigger things in store for former SVG Consul General to Toronto – PM
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    A higher posting will be offered to former SVG Consul General to Toronto, Fitz Huggins, who recently demitted office. Huggins concluded his ambassador...
    Venezuelans  remain resillent, determined  despite massive sanctions by US
    Front Page
    Venezuelans remain resillent, determined despite massive sanctions by US
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    Over $20 billion in Venezuelan assets abroad remain frozen, while the country has suffered a 99% loss of foreign income since February, 2014. But desp...
    PM not ready to ‘ring the bell’ at ULP Layou rally
    Front Page
    PM not ready to ‘ring the bell’ at ULP Layou rally
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    While many may have felt the date for the general elections in St. Vincent and the Grenadines would have been announced at the Unity Labour Party’s ‘W...
    Schools get in on World Food Day celebrations
    Front Page
    Schools get in on World Food Day celebrations
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    World Food Day, celebrated annually across the globe on October, 16, to commemorate the date of the founding of the United Nations (UN) Food and Agric...
    Mitres makes history as inaugural Semi-Pro Netball Champions
    Sports
    Mitres makes history as inaugural Semi-Pro Netball Champions
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    Mitres Netball Team wrote their name into local netball history, when they captured the inaugural Semi-Professional Netball League title on Wednesday ...
    News
    More than 1000 families have received appliances says PM
    News
    More than 1000 families have received appliances says PM
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    The government’s allocation of $1.5 million in the 2025 budget to provide essential household appliances, including refrigerators, stoves, and washing...
    Urban transformation to follow Kingstown Port opening
    News
    Urban transformation to follow Kingstown Port opening
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    Minister with responsibility for urban development, airports and seaports, Senator Bernarva Browne, is looking forwards to the start of much bigger th...
    New York Times claims cocaine washed up in Grenadines
    News
    New York Times claims cocaine washed up in Grenadines
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    On October 14, 2025, The New York Times, in an article headlined “Drug Smugglers Change Supply Routes to Evade U.S. Warships”, showed a photograph of ...
    This election is a galaxy of stars, says Gonsalves
    News
    This election is a galaxy of stars, says Gonsalves
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    The upcoming general elections in St Vincent and the Grenadines will be about the ability of the political candidates to shine. That is the conclusion...
    Vote without fear – Senator John
    News
    Vote without fear – Senator John
    Webmaster 
    October 17, 2025
    Electors waiting to vote in the next general elections are being asked to do so without fear as the ballot is secret and no one can know who you voted...

    E-EDITION
    ePaper
    google_play
    app_store
    Subscribe Now
    • Interactive Media Ltd. • P.O. Box 152 • Kingstown • St. Vincent and the Grenadines • Phone: 784-456-1558 © Copyright Interactive Media Ltd.. All rights reserved.
    We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok